Thursday, January 08, 2009

Wooden Ships


Communism and socialism made enormous inroads among the American population in the early days of what used to be called the Great Depression, and the thousands-strong "Bonus Army" of veterans demanding government relief was swept from the streets of D.C. by armed and mounted U.S. troops under the command of Douglas MacArthur.

Then FD Roosevelt stepped in like Superman to defuse any moves toward open revolt. The New Deal co-opted the revolution.

Then came the war, the fifties, and the rise of the mega-corporations and the warfare state.

Forty years ago, a lot of us echoed David Crosby saying, "We are leaving; you don't need us," and attempted to drop out of an American society we had come to regard with horror and revulsion.

But not enough people took part in that movement, and those of us who did shortly became faint of heart and dropped back in. We should have stuck to our guns, or maybe I should say, our carrots.

At the time we might be heard to say that "The system has become a machine, and the machine is out of control." But it's difficult to be so right when you're young, because being inexperienced, you can never be sure of yourself.

But now I see how right we were, and that America has become a gigantic, out-of-control monster robot, fueled by war and endlessly reproducing the mindless capitalist cycle of recovery, boom, mania, panic, and collapse.

The revolution will come because it's inevitable. It's inevitable because we can't live this way. As Karl Marx observed, we can no longer live with the continued existence of this ruling class, because its continued existence is incompatible with society.

He meant it's incompatible with orderly, functioning social organization of any kind, and he was right.

7 comments:

Joe said...

Indeed. Marx incorporated the teachings of philosophers into a system that we now understand was poorly tried in Russia and elsewhere. The present system of animalistic competition was ingrained into the minds of the public as a religion, in part to counter the civilized religion of Marx and Socrates.

Joe said...

Cooperation is much better for just social conditions than competition. The Greek state knew that and killed Socrates. The leaders of our country knew likewise and did as you said to su/oppress the public.

©∂†ß0X∑® said...

I think I'll do a Karl Marx thread on the "other" site.

Joe said...

That could get interesting. About the best argument I've seen to support the survival of the fittest mentality is that people must be threatened in order to be motivated. It's evil. Some evil is necessary, you know. You might want to decide not to start that discussion.

Sator Arepo said...

Um.

I didn't make it up, but I've said it before and I'll say it again:

The means of production must belong to the worker.

Heh.

regards,
SA

Joe said...

When the workers own the means of production, the products are better and the workers are happier.

Sator Arepo said...

Indeed,

SA